Performance Improvement Plans (PIPs) Explained: A Comprehensive Guide

Performance issues are an inevitable challenge for every organization, but how they’re addressed can shape your culture and define your employee experience. A Performance Improvement Plan (PIP) is a structured, supportive, and legally sound framework that enables underperforming employees to get back on track. Rather than functioning as a disciplinary shortcut, a well-crafted PIP is an opportunity for coaching, clarity, and course correction. In this comprehensive guide, we break down the what, when, how, and why of PIPs, and show how GalleryHR’s tools make managing this process more effective and human-centered.

What Is a Performance Improvement Plan?

A PIP is a formal document designed to help employees who are not meeting job expectations understand what needs to change, how success will be measured, and what resources are available to support improvement. It typically includes:

• Performance Gaps: A detailed summary of behaviors, metrics, or outcomes that are not meeting expectations

• SMART Goals: Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, and Time-bound objectives for improvement

• Timelines: Clear deadlines and check-in intervals for reviewing progress

• Resources: Access to training, mentorship, and any necessary tools or materials

• Outcomes: Explanation of possible consequences if goals are not met

When Should a PIP Be Used?

A PIP should be considered after informal coaching and regular feedback have not led to improvement. It should never be a surprise to the employee—it should reflect issues that have already been raised.

Appropriate Scenarios for a PIP:

• Underperformance in critical areas (e.g., missed targets, low quality of work)

• Behavioral concerns (e.g., poor collaboration, disruptive communication style)

• Policy violations that don’t warrant immediate termination

• Inconsistent attendance or reliability

• Concerns about capability following a role change or promotion

How to Design and Deliver an Effective PIP

An effective PIP is built on clarity, consistency, and support. Here’s how to implement one step-by-step:

1. Conduct a Root Cause Analysis

Before drafting a PIP, understand the underlying cause of the performance issue. Is it a skills gap? A lack of resources? A mismatch in expectations?

2. Collaboratively Define Expectations

Engage the employee in a two-way conversation. Use specific examples to explain what’s not working, and discuss the business impact.

3. Build SMART Goals

Goals must be clear, attainable, and directly tied to the employee’s role. Avoid vague language—be data-driven and role-specific.

4. Structure the Timeline and Reviews

Typical PIPs last between 30 to 90 days. Schedule formal check-ins at agreed intervals (e.g., weekly) to review progress and adjust as needed.

5. Offer Support and Resources

This could include pairing with a mentor, additional training, shadowing, or toolkits. Document the resources being provided.

6. Provide Transparent Documentation

Summarize the plan in a signed document, and share a copy with the employee. Ensure they know it is not a guaranteed path to dismissal—it’s a chance to improve.

7. Conclude the PIP Fairly

At the end of the plan, evaluate whether goals have been met. Possible outcomes include successful completion, an extension, reassignment, or—in some cases—termination.

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

• Using a PIP as a formality before termination instead of a genuine improvement tool

• Vague goals or undefined success metrics that confuse employees

• Failing to follow through on support promised during the process

• Inconsistent application across teams that leads to bias or perceived unfairness

Legal and Compliance Considerations

PIPs must be applied fairly, consistently, and in accordance with employment law. Avoid legal risks by:

• Providing adequate time and realistic goals

• Documenting each step of the process and employee response

• Avoiding discriminatory or retaliatory use

• Reviewing with legal counsel or HR before issuing a PIP in sensitive cases

• Ensuring confidentiality throughout the process

 

How GalleryHR Supports Performance Improvement Plans

GalleryHR offers an end-to-end performance management suite that supports every step of the PIP lifecycle:

1. Pre-Built and Customizable PIP Templates

Use pre-approved templates tailored by department or role, or build your own with our intuitive editor.

2. Integrated Performance Tracking

Track goals, progress, and feedback in real time using dynamic dashboards and automated reminders.

3. Manager Coaching Tools

Equip supervisors with scripts, coaching tips, and documentation guides to conduct PIP conversations with empathy and clarity.

4. Legal Safeguards

Ensure your documentation meets compliance requirements and is reviewed by legal advisors built into the platform.

5. Reporting and Insights

Identify recurring trends, time-to-resolution data, and success rates across teams to inform better leadership practices.

 

Conclusion

A well-executed PIP doesn’t just protect your business, it elevates it. When approached with transparency and genuine intent, performance improvement plans can turn struggling employees into star performers and transform leadership into better coaches. Done poorly, they lead to disengagement and legal risk. Done well, they’re a sign of a healthy, high-accountability culture.

With GalleryHR, you can take the guesswork out of performance correction and build a team that improves with purpose.

 

Don’t miss this opportunity to upgrade your HR operations and join the growing list of businesses in Sri Lanka achieving success with GalleryHR.

GalleryHR is committed to helping Sri Lankan businesses thrive with smarter, more efficient HR solutions. Partner with us today and experience the difference.

Join our empire today!